
NATHAN
Reviews


Rattray's - Accountant's Mixture 100g
Fantastic Scottish Blend
Stays in my rotation. I'm never disappointed by this. Balanced and flavorful.


Savinelli - Janus 2oz
Good quality
With some aging, I've grown fond of Janus. It's flavorful and satisfying.


Hearth & Home - Fusilier's Ration 1.75oz
Ages well, rich and tasty
The Latakia is prominent for me. Taste of leather, fruit, and chocolate after aging a few months.


Cornell & Diehl - Mocha
Goopy, not bad
A little goopy. The topping is overbearing and get hot. The aroma is excellent.


Cornell & Diehl - Black Gold Maple
Pass
I find the taste unpleasant. I won't buy it again. It lights and burns well, but I was hoping for at least some maple flavor.


Cornell & Diehl - Epiphany
Just Great
Tastes good, no bite. Reminiscent of Mountain Camp but without the spice. This will stay in my rotation.


Sutliff - Anomalous 50g
Neat. Sweet. Perique.
Good Va/Per blend. I wish I had a lifetime supply. It is spicy like black pepper, and does develop darker notes with age.


Sutliff - 507C Virginia Slices
Good flavor and spice
Very flavorful - as flakes tend to be. Black pepper and grassy hay notes. No complaints.


Cornell & Diehl - Odessa
Works for me.
I like it. Well rounded. I can taste the sourness and spice, so I can get my fix when I get a hankering for it.


Borkum Riff - Original 1.5oz
Good smoke but gets hot
I could taste the fruit flavor. Like a sour plum in a good way. It does get hot though, there is some steam at times. Dry it out a little.


Half and Half - Half and Half 1.5oz
Can't go wrong
Sweet and rich, I'd offer this to anyone. Good anytime, but it can bite.


Cornell & Diehl - Byzantium
Rich and Pleasing
A good buy. I enjoy the flavors and aroma. Pretty rich and intricate


Cornell & Diehl - Chopped Cigar Leaf
Powerful
Pretty powerful. I'd use it to beef up weaker blends. Once in a while, having a bowl plain hits the spot.


Grand Croupier - Jack Pot
Economical Go-to
This will be my go to when I need to save some money, but it's not a blend I'd go out of my way for.


Cornell & Diehl - Mountain Camp
My preferred pick any time of day.
If I could only smoke one blend for the rest of my life, it would be Mountain Camp. Great black pepper notes and flavorful Latakia. I'd smoke it after lunch or dinner. The trouble with smoking all the time is eventually I run out, so I have to switch it up, much to my chagrin.


Stanwell - Melange 50g
Not my favorite
Tends to get hot. The tin note is the best I've ever smelled, but the flavor doesn't measure up.


Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust - Umbagog Corona Gorda
Not Bad - Not for me
It's not a bad cigar. I get choked up on the spice. Glad I gave it a shot but won't be getting again. Not for me.


Perdomo - Reserve Champagne 10th Anniversary Churchill
A Pleasure - Mild - Quality
This was my first cigar. I did a lot of research for finding the right cigar, and Perdomo was definitely right for me. The Churchill stick lasted me 2 hours. Flavor was more mild than I expected. I'd offer this to guests, family, or my boss with confidence.