Tobacco Pipes Search
|
|
Mathew W.
Reviews
Rocky Patel - Java Mint Toro
What a disappointment
My own fault, but I didn't notice the "mint" label. Not at all what I was looking for, but I can say it's very reminiscent of a peppermint patty. When considered for what it is, I think it's probably very good, and if you're looking for a mint cigar, you may be very happy with this.
Toscano - Duecento
Pretty good
Fit and finish is no better than other offerings from Toscano. Not overly harsh; dark, chocolatey, some wood. Worth $10 per ($5 per half)? I'm not sure, leaning towards no. By no means bad, just not exceptional to my taste. There are better options for the price.
Toscano - Modigliani (5 Pack)
Pretty good
Very light in comparison to the rest of the lineup, even weak. Almost no discomfort in the retrohale. What is here is entirely pleasant, sweet light chocolate mainly. Could be a good introduction to the format for a new smoker.
Toscano - Toscanello Natural (5 Pack)
Excellent
Decent price, satisfying. Woody, slightly sweet. Worth trying for sure; may start stocking up, I like the form factor of the cut halves in the pocket sized pack. Good enough to be a daily smoke.
Toscano - StilNovo (3 Pack)
Pretty good
The packaging is excessive, but I didn't notice any uneven burn as the last reviewer did. Smoked in halves. Very dark, slightly bitter chocolate, mainly. Revisiting the second half, coming across very bitter and slightly sweet. I can imagine this being somebody's thing, but it's not mine.
G. L. Pease - Westminster 2oz
Solid English
After smoking through probably a couple dozen English blends, this seems to be comparatively low on sweetness and complexity, smokiness is really front and center. Maybe wood and leather, nothing fruity or vegetal. Reminds me of a dreary, rainy day; not necessarily a bad thing, sometimes it's appropriate. Burns great. It's not an all day smoke for me, but I'm glad to have it on hand.
G. L. Pease - Westminster 2oz
Solid English
After smoking through probably a couple dozen English blends, this seems to be comparatively low on sweetness and complexity, smokiness is really front and center. Maybe wood and leather, nothing fruity or vegetal. Reminds me of a dreary, rainy day; not necessarily a bad thing, sometimes it's appropriate. Burns great. It's not an all day smoke for me, but I'm glad to have it on hand.
G. L. Pease - Westminster 2oz
Solid English
After smoking through probably a couple dozen English blends, this seems to be comparatively low on sweetness and complexity, smokiness is really front and center. Maybe wood and leather, nothing fruity or vegetal. Reminds me of a dreary, rainy day; not necessarily a bad thing, sometimes it's appropriate. Burns great. It's not an all day smoke for me, but I'm glad to have it on hand.
Cain - F 738 Lancero
Okay
Not really doing it for me, lacks complexity. Nothing off putting about it really, just not satisfying. Probably say it's priced right, worth sampling at least.
Bolivar - Cofradia No. 554
Excellent
Novice cigar enthusiast, this is excellent. Worth more than the going rate, excellent value. I put this firmly in the chocolate camp. Not the best I've had, but I could see this being a daily smoke.
Padron - Maduro 3000
Outstanding
Been smoking a pipe for a year or two, new cigar smoker. This was amazing, very sweet and dessert-like in the mouth, strong coffee/dark chocolate in the retrohale. Worth more than the going rate. Unless I find something strictly better within the selection I'm smoking my way through, I plan to buy more of these.
HVC - Hot Cake Golden Line Corona Gorda
Fair
Been smoking a pipe for a year or two, just getting into cigars. This is very, very mild, too mild for my tastes. Nothing unpleasant here though, lightly sweet and dessert-like. Would purchase again if they were significantly cheaper.
