Carl K.

Cobblestone - Brick Burley Plug 1.75oz
Full flavored and well balanced. A top 10 for me.

Ashton - Gold Rush 50g
Really Good
There are bad Virginias and great Virginias, this is a really good Virginia. It smokes easily and will surprise you with a rich fruit flavor in the second half of the bowl. I reach for this when I want any easy smoking Virginia that I don't need to rub out. Much better than similarly priced American Virginias.

Newminster - No.400 Superior Navy Flake
Really solid Virginia
Great grass and hay flavor, easy to smoke, by far my favorite anytime Virginia. I stopped at four stars because I haven't coaxed much complexity of it, but I'm buying a half pound more.

Rattray's - Bagpiper's Dream 100g
One of my go to holiday blends
A very well done aromatic. I don't smoke a lot of them. I reserve this for the holidays. Has a hint of cherry to me.

Sillem's - Mayor 1814 Flake 50g
Very nice tobacco
One of the few my wife likes the smell of... If you like Erinmore Flake, you'll like this.

Currently there are no favorite products