Cornell & Diehl - Berry Good
Not "berry good"
Tin note is powerful.... room note.... not so much, no trace of berry in the smoke at all. burns very cool, and stays lit very well. Sad news is I purchased 4oz of the stuff before I tried it, now I've gotta find some poor sucker who will trade me something smokeable for it. Don't waste your money if you're looking for anything that the name suggests.
Cornell & Diehl - Green River Vanilla
Green River "Vanilla"
The Vanilla seems to be more in the room and tin note. Not getting much distinguishable vanilla in the flavor. Plenty of flavor, but not so much Vanilla flavor. Tobacco was rather wet even for a dark Cavendish base. I'll keep at it and revisit this review later.
Sutliff - Black Raspberry
not over done
The pouch note is very nice on this tobacco. I have smoked several of Sutliff's fruity blends and I must say this one is very well understated. This could have gone in a much different direction, but it does Black Raspberry very well, and allows the under lying tobaccos to come through easily. You could easily expect this to be something reminiscent of what IHOP would offer to top pancakes, but it wasn't. I enjoyed it very much.
Sutliff - 150 Mark Twain
Tried a friends selection of this while sitting on the patio one night. I was truly, shocked at how much I liked it. Normally, when I see a name drop like "Mark Twain" I am seeing an idea being sold and not particularly a quality all together. I've never been upset with a sutliff tobacco, and this is also far from offending me, or the wife.
Sutliff - SPS 2011 - Peach Cobbler
If you like Peach, but not to death.
A well balanced peach that doesn't kill you or your pipe. I get lots of compliments about the "room note" this gives. Flavor stays for the whole bowl for me, and doesn't smoke wet. Regular in the rotation.
Sutliff - 1M
Fantastically well balanced aromatic. Good to have around for those who are looking for a mellow slow smoke. Ages nicely as well.
Sutliff - Frosty Mint
not just for parties anymore
I'm going to admit it.... I got it as a joke... to try something so far out of the bag..... it even tainted the bag of tobacco it was shipped with. But honestly, It improved what would have otherwise been something I didn't prefer. Mint for days, works great with adding a tiny bit to any bowl of aromatic for a change. I would suspect it will "ghost" any bowl it is smoked in. Don't expect anything other than what it says it is. Mike Tyson is going to punch you in the face with glorious mintyness.
Sutliff - SPS-2003 Strawberry Delight
full 5 stars for being exactly what it says it is
strawberry out of your face. if you don't like the idea of smoking something more akin to hookah aroma than a virginia, then this won't be your speed at all. Not an every day smoker for me by any means, but great fun to smoke.
Planta - Anno MMVI (Sweet Pear Mixture)
Echo what others are saying
This was a gift from a friend. I would like to give it more time to see if it grows on me more. Nothing bad about it at all. Nice thing to change the pace a little.
Planta - Anno MMXIV (Fruity and Fragrant)
Name says it all
Smoking this straight and you'll get what others have described as potpourri. Not saying that is a bad thing, but it's surely something different. I didn't find that fact off putting as I knew it would be exactly as I expected. Works well in a blend with some straight cavendish if you're wanting a little spin from the usual.
Sutliff - 507C Virginia Slices
I bought this in order to try a straight Virginia. Not my speed of Tobacco, but clearly a good example of Virginia is. Nothing off putting and nothing bad about it at all.
Peter Stokkebye - PS403 Luxury Bullseye Flake
not sure what i was expecting
I bought this on a whim when it was on sale. Not sure what I was expecting, but I can't say I was steered either way on initial smoke. Nothing particular stands out. Got it locked away and will revisit in a few months.
Peterson - University Flake 50g
found it lacking
don't get me wrong, it's not bad at all... but I was attracted by the description and let down by the smoke. Found it unremarkable really.
Samuel Gawith - Mayor's Chocolate Flake 50g
Holy smokey Chocolate!
You sly little devils have done it again! I would have NEVER imagined I would have enjoyed a chocolate with latikia but this, wow... amazing
Savinelli - Black Cavendish 50g
Advertised as a Black Cavendish, but it's a Black Cavendish blend. Somewhat disappointing if that's what you're expecting, but still a VERY enjoyable and pleasant smoke.
Mac Baren - Cherry Ambrosia 100g
Color me shocked!
Not sure what I was expecting when I purchased this other than the usual "cherry aromatic" but wow, this is NOT your typical Cherry Aromatic. Fantastic light, smooth smoke, the Virginia really lightens this up. Not sugary like many other Cherry cavendish blends.
Lane Limited - 1-Q
Good for what it is
If you like something not quite aromatic, but not quite Virginia, then this is probably going to meet the ticket.
Cornell & Diehl - Black Cavendish
Nice all round
I purchased this with 3 other nonblend Black Cavendish offered by other makers. This comes in a strong second for me. Nothing over stated, and also nothing special. Mot people would never smoke BC straight, but people used to never drink unblended scotch until someone explained to them the finer side of how to taste it. I would say you could enhance this with a blend, but it surely doesn't need to be cut with anything else.
Lane Limited - BCA
Everyone Said Lane BCA
That's the one to beat. I can't seem to agree. It's a good Cavendish, of that there is no argument, but I feel this is better as something to blend with vs smoking straight. Maybe that's something others will find as obvious, but after 20+ years of smoking unblended Black Cavendish straight I can say this one is not one I will return to with out using it in a mix.
Sutliff - Aged Maduro Cavendish
Maybe the best I've ever smoked
I've been a fan of Black Cavendish since I started puffing my pipe over 20 years ago. I have my English blends, and my Syrian leanings from time to time, but I always return to the Black Cavendish I first enjoyed. This for sure is the most well stated rendition I've ever smoked. Nothing over stated, nothing over the top. It's the perfect balance that everyone else is trying to match.
Peter Stokkebye - PS201 Black Cavendish
Top notch straight Black Cavendish
I grabbed all the Straight Black Cavendish that the site offers in order to compare them. This is for sure one of the best pure/straight BC that I've ever had. Not too over powering with topping and smokes mellow and nice till the bottom. Not overly damp and had no issue with relight. If you know how to smoke an aromatic, then this will give you no problems either.