Customer Reviews (31 Total)
Mild BurleyBlend
December 05, 2017
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 14oz
Finally found a mild blend that is burley based.
Nothing like the original..
May 27, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
But well worth the price for a decent Burley smoke. Arrives a bit moist for my liking, so if you find it gives you a bite do what I do with overly moist tobacco’s. This blend required a full 4 days of air drying. Absolutely no bite and this also brou... Read More
ght out the nuttiness of the Burley. The cocoa is WAY in the background of this blend but you do get that sweetness you’d expect from the Burley tobacco. It’s a 3 STAR blend. Read Less
What's In A Name?
August 09, 2015
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 14oz
I'm comparing my 14 ounce tin of the reintroduced Edgeworth RR renamed as Lane Ltd RR with half a 14 ounce tin of Lane's ERR which is about 10 years old. Other than the older tin's contents having a slightly darker presence from aging, Lane's reintro... Read More
duction of this classic has hit all of the previous marks, smoking identical to its predecessor. However, it is not a true cube cut as stated by some. A very comforting and perhaps the best of the Codger Burleys out there. As I am primarily a Burley smoker, I'm very happy that it is back. A bit of what I assumed was PG in the mix, not getting in the way too much, has since faded from my tin and bowl. Very well done, and as such I give it a 5 star review. I much prefer a flake variety of Burley, and a stouter Burley at that, such as Solani's ABF, Wessex Burley Slice, or the defunct Edgeworth Sliced...now that would be something I would look forward to being reintroduced! Read Less
A nice blend that helped change my mind about Burley.
December 28, 2019
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
I had been on a long journey to expand my palate and figure out what so many pipe smokers saw in Burley tobaccos when Lane Limited re-introduced Ready Rubbed to the world. It got so much attention, some founded in truth, some in nostalgia for the lon... Read More
g-gone Edgeworth Ready Rubbed of the past, that it had my attention and I had to try it. Having had other Burley blends that soured or turned to a cigarette taste quickly, I found Lane's Ready Rubbed to be quite the opposite. I actually enjoyed it as a light, soft, all-day blend. It didn't take long to finish the pouch, less than a week as I recall. I haven't yet plopped down the cash for a tub, but I have occasionally sought another pouch. The tobacco is a wide ribbon cut that is easy to pack and light. The flavor is faint but redolent of hot chocolate. I do wish this flavor came out a little more, especially since there's not a very strong Burley flavor either. Perhaps that's why I liked this as a Burley explorer? As such, I would consider this a great blend for first-timers, either new to pipe smoking or new to Burley blends. It didn't bite me at all. Being a fan of lots of different styles of tobacco, and having weathered some of the worst aromatics and Virginias for bite, I rarely get tongue bite anymore. Having said that, if you get tongue bite from Lane Limited's Ready Rubbed, something went way, way wrong! Now, in all seriousness and for full disclosure, Sutliff also makes a match for Edgeworth's Ready Rubbed and it is actually the one I prefer. I don't like to compare the two though, I like them both for different reasons. I feel that the Sutliff version should please more experienced pipe smokers looking for a heartier blend with a bit more nicotine oomph. Two different blends, meant to be replacements for one of the greatest selling blends of a bygone age, spanning patrons of the hobby from beginner to veteran smokers alike. Give them both a try and I'd bet you'll like one or the other, if not both. Enjoy. Read Less
All day allnight
June 03, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
Wow. This is awesome. Im not what u would call a burley lover but i do enjoy it. And this stuff cant be beat. Its the luxury navy flake of burleus. Its inexpensive and tastes great. Gry it u wont be dissapointed
Mildly Aromatic
August 29, 2019
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
This is a mild aromatic blend with virtually no tongue bite. It is not something I write home about. Just an average all day smoke. Don't have anything bad against it, just wish it was more complex, like BCA.
4.00 stars?!
May 11, 2019
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
At least that's what it was before I just awarded it two. And it DOES bite; I didn't read Ionecoyote's review (05/27/18) soon enough. I revisited this one after my last bowl of Edgeworth,, in Mexico City circa 1965, for reasons of curiosity and nos... Read More
talgia. It was dear old dad's smoke of choice. Not that he ever HAD much choice given that the drug store was our town's only tobacconist. Daddy, it must be said, possessed all of three pipes, which lived in the back of his top right desk drawer and seemingly were brought out only on special occasions. I reckon he got started on pipes to impress the ladies back in college. Regardless, it never really took, and he regressed to smoking full-strength Winstons and not surprisingly dying of lung cancer at age 72. Bottom line: Of the two Edgeworth imitations, Sutliff Ready Rubbed Match is the better. Read Less
Burley Lovers MUST Try This Classic OTC
April 04, 2019
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
This is an American Classic. Lane Limited must have retained the recipe, because it tastes and smells just like the Edgeworth RR I smoked in college. Very mild hints of cocoa or coffee bean, but the burley is the star of this show. The aroma is one y... Read More
ou'll never forget. This is not your typical "aro", but rather, a tobacco lover's blend. So good. If you like a nice, smooth, no bite, no muss or fuss all day smoke - this may be the one. Read Less
Think Cigarettes
July 18, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
[Tin/pouch - Vinegar nose tin first whiff. Sour note. Beautiful nutty brown sugary bowl sniff (very light).]
Woody on smoke. Molasses on exhale giving to nuttiness hint. Mostly bland tobacco. (Lasting first impression: think cigarettes).
I... Read More
f sampling through Burleys, it is a good part of that experience, but PS Toasted Burley blows this one away IMO. ◄3/10✠Skulls► Read Less
Smooth and mild
June 10, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
Smokeable straight from the pouch for me. Very mild aroma of nutty burley. Packs and burns well. Flavros are subtle nuttiness and some earthy Virginia. Mild all the way through. Very relaxing smoke. In a world of extreme blends and boutique blends, t... Read More
his is a welcomed change of pace. Can be an all day smoke. Read Less
STILL THE SAME 👌🏼
September 20, 2020
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 14oz
I am smoking Edgeworth RR from 1987 I just opened, the other day I smoked LLRR and other than age all the same notes of cocoa, molasses, rum are here just more mellow and not up front. The difference I can tell is actually the Aroma from the bowl whi... Read More
ch is just a little richer in smell but not in any other way different, as any well aged tobacco would be. I think I prefer the smoke of a new LLRR getting all these notes more pronounced but I give bowl/Room note to the aged Edgeworth RR. I will grab a tub or two just to age. It's nice to see for myself the tobacco hasn't changed and why would it since Lane was already the ones producing it. Read Less
Really good burley
April 30, 2020
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 14oz
This is a go to burley even for those who don’t like burley. Has a taste that reminds me of roasting marshmallows on a campfire.
Hot damn
February 17, 2020
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 14oz
Though I did not purchase from SP this blend is superbly mild. No chemical taste like prince albert.
This made me want to smoke all the time....
May 20, 2019
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
This is the burley blend that for me is really delicious, compare to burley blend like Solani ABF. This one have mild nicotine but have a same taste with solani ABF so that can be everyday & every time smoke. Awesome!
Not superb but deserve 4 stars
August 13, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
When i opened the pouch i smell cigarette and was amazed to taste and smell it when it burns, it is pipe tobacco.
As the title, it is not a superb pipe blend but a decent one, very decent.
However, be careful of a light tongue bite a head as the bo... Read More
wl progresses, it could be a medium to strong bite if you smoke fast.
By the way, i don't think it is a ready rubbed or a broken flake form, i think this much more like cube cut burley and pretty small cube.
Give it a try and i'm afraid that you'd have a second try, third try and .... countless try since you can't beat this price. Read Less
Nice all day smoke
August 12, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
Ordered this blend based on a video review and I'm glad I did?
Nice all day smoke
August 12, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
Ordered this blend based on a video review and I'm glad I did!
Very good sll day burley
July 15, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
Not what I expected. A very pleasing smoke. Easy to light and burns great. Not many relights and does not bite. Faint flavors of cocoa and molasses. An all day smoke that is worth the try.
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
A very simple, mild, straight forward tobacco. The cut and moisture were near perfect for loading the pipe. First impression on lighting up was the nutty burley, followed by a faint hint of chocolate. Towards the end of the bowl the grassy Virginians... Read More
kicked in just a bit. Never did taste any molasses. This is definitely a mild all day smoke. Read Less
move over carter!
March 18, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
This is a no nonsense OTC burley blend. easy to pack, tastes great, tangy with some cocoa. does not have that nasty chemical taste of CH. doesnt bite, has decent room note and pleasant aftertaste. probably works well for breaking in a pipe. certainly... Read More
worth a try. Read Less
Step back in time...
March 17, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 14oz
A go to blend for me. I love everything about it.
Exactly What I Was Hoping For.
February 26, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 14oz
This is pretty much exactly what I was hoping it would be. Tastes a lot like a rubbed out Wessex Burley Slice and at a much cheaper price point. It comes at perfect moisture level for smoking right out of the tub. This is a meant to be the rubbed out... Read More
Edgeworth Slices and Wessex is meant to be Edgeworth Slices so it makes sense that they taste similar. Nicotine is low so it’s perfect to load up and smoke several times a day. It’s not complex so you don’t need to contemplate the smoke itself and therefor makes a perfect “chore tobacco” while running around doing “honey do’s”. All in all, it’s a good dumb reach and I’m glad I have it as an option. Everything about this tobacco is mild. My only complaint is that it burns too quick but I guess you could turn that into a pro as it makes a good quick smoke. I might try cutting it with some Brown Bogie to add some nicotine to the mix. Read Less
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 14oz
Burley flavored lightly with molasses, cocoa, and anise. What more can you ask, an old school favorite !
Cool and Tasty with thick clouds of smoke.
A Pleasant Surprise!
February 11, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
I never expect much from a pouch, but I was looking for a nice, cocoa tasting burley. Carter Hall sounded like what I was looking for, but it burns too quickly and has a chemical flavor hiding in it. This Lane has all of what I wanted out of Carter H... Read More
all, without the gross background chemical note I hate. I always enjoy bowls of Lane Ready Rubbed. For the price, you can't go wrong! Read Less
It's worth a try
January 31, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
I was happy to see that this is now available in a pouch, as I didn't want to order the big tin and be stuck with something disappointing. This packs well, lights quickly, and burns evenly, but at times a little fast. It also leaves some wet dottle a... Read More
t the bottom of the bowl. The chocolate and molasses scent is present in the Mason jar, but not always in the bowl. I have noticed, though, that as I work my way down to the bottom of the jar, the flavor improves. But it has a good rugged burley taste to it, and the price and availability are a plus. I rate this 3.5 stars on its own, with a half star for the price and availability. It's not as good as Gawith and Hoggarth's Black and Brown, but it's worth a try. Read Less
Good but,
January 31, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
this is based on my first try of this baccy, while I find the taste, being smooth,light and has hints of cocoa and molasses
the meantime I've come to a realisation, to my surprice this has a tendency to bite
Am doing something wrong?Perhaps I ought... Read More
to have dry this more prior to smoke, this baccy has obviously high PC contents,as usual when smoking Burley forward blends I have hardly encountered any biting issues, let take the Carter Hall to compare with which I had much better experience.Nevertheless,this Lane tastes great no doubt and it deserves second change Read Less
Can't stop smoking it!
January 10, 2018
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 14oz
I love this stuff. It's such a nice smoke for any time or place. Easy to pack, lots of volume, smooth to taste, and a steady burn, there's no wonder it's a famed classic. Bravo!
Old classic...
December 15, 2017
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 1.5oz
One of the all time great Burley staples. This tobacco has been around for years but more commonly known as Edgeworth ready rubbed. An absolute must for all those Burley lovers. Hints of Cocoa and molasses. All day smoke. Nothing fancy.
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 14oz
Yumm. Love the burley's and it is definitely a classic.
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 14oz
a friend bought some and I tried it found it okay nothing too exciting
Product: Lane Limited Ready Rubbed 14oz
My dad smoke ERR and when I started a pipe in the early 1970's that was the blend I started with. So, I'm working off of a 40yr old memory. Everything about this tobacco seemed different. The color, the cut and the aroma from the can. Not the cool sm... Read More
oke I remembered either. Read Less
The Pipe Locator
|
|
