How to Select Your First Pipe

How to choose you first pipe

Many current pipe smokers started abruptly, finding themselves one day exploring the possibility of pipe smoking without a clear reason. Perhaps we observed the contentment and appreciation experienced by a pipe smoker in our own lives or in novels or films and wanted to experience that satisfaction for ourselves. Whatever the reasons, subconscious or overt, we became curious and started investigating.

Buying a pipe is intimidating when we start this journey: so many shapes, materials, sizes; vulcanite or acrylic mouthpieces; pipes with and without filters, with and without systems to reduce moisture; smooth, sandblasted, rusticated, and carved finishes — each manifested in complex sculptural shapes or those more traditionally inclined. Without a frame of reference to help us judge, the choices can become exhausting. That may be why you're here: to maximize the likelihood of success, either because you've not yet tried pipe smoking or have found that it isn't working out.

Pipes last forever if properly smoked and maintained. The first pipe you buy may still be in your collection 40 years from now, though it's likely that your tastes will change over time and you'll sell that pipe to help fund a new one. Part of the fun of pipes is branching out, trying new tobaccos and pipes, and modifying pipe collections.

As for the collecting aspect, one needn't accumulate dozens of pipes, though it's often difficult to avoid as pipes become more personally important. A collection can be two pipes or 500. After finding whether or not pipes are something you want to pursue, a rotation of at least a couple of pipes will help you appreciate your tobacco more because pipes smoke better when they're given a rest, though lots of folks smoke the same pipe all day long.

Still, moisture accumulates in a pipe as a natural result of combustion. As the tobacco is transformed into smoke, its water content has to go somewhere, and much of it is absorbed by the pipe, so it makes sense to let that pipe dry for a day or so after it's smoked. Multiple pipes are not essential, especially at the beginning stages when it's unlikely that a pipe will be asked to perform multiple back-to-back smokes, but it's something to keep in mind for the future. One pipe, however, will suffice until one knows if smoking is appealing.

You and your pipe are partners. Neither of you can do the job alone, so compatibility is key. Just as you wouldn't buy clothing that doesn't fit your style in color or practicability, you would be best served in not buying a pipe that mismatches your tastes and personality.

That still leaves thousands of permutations of shape, size, bowl dimensions, grain, texture, stem material and color, bowl medium, and yes, personality to assess. Where to begin?

The Standards that Every Pipe Should Fulfill

For a particular pipe to be a good option, four categories should be considered: Aesthetic, Mechanical, Financial, and Metaphysical. These four pillars of pipe selection will help narrow the choices in every pipe purchase, providing the knowledge and confidence to select a well-made pipe that is appealing, affordable, that will provide decades of smoking enjoyment, and that fulfills expectations for a long-term companion.


A tobacco pipe should resonate with your personal sense of style

A pipe should resonate with your personal sense of style. Everyone is attracted to different artistic aspects of art, film, literature, and every other creative pursuit, including pipes. What other people like is immaterial. A pipe is something to build a relationship with, and that is not possible if its style fails to meet your personal preferences. Maybe it seemed okay at first, and its inadequate style was superseded by great engineering, a well-known maker, and a bargain price. Even with all of that in its favor, you're unlikely to enjoy that pipe to its potential if you simply don't like its proportions or finish or shape. Be sure that any pipe you purchase is attractive to you personally.

So, the first rule is: Buy pipes you like. That may seem over-intuitive but it's an essential tenet. Still, when you're new to pipe smoking, you may not be entirely sure of what types of pipes suit you best or excite you most; that comes with a little more experience. The best advice in that case is to look at pipes — lots of pipes. Take every opportunity to check out interesting selections. Look at all of the different pipe styles. Inevitably, a particular pipe will fill you with infatuation and, despite being nonverbal, it will tell you in no uncertain terms that you need it in your collection. When this personal conversation materializes, be prepared to move on to the next aspect of pipe buying: the physical inspection.

Mechanical Considerations:

The tobacco pipe must be constructed in such a manner as to bring you pleasure from smoking it

The pipe must be constructed in such a manner as to bring you pleasure from smoking it. Otherwise, there is no point. It must not have design flaws that cause it to be impossible to keep clean, lit, or even together. Its airflow must be unimpeded by misalignment of mortise and tenon or a poorly fitting stem. The question, especially for beginning pipe smokers, is how to identify a well-made pipe. It's best to arm yourself with the knowledge to recognize the difference between a well-made pipe and a poorly made pipe. A good starting point is to know what to avoid.

The presence of any one of the following negative aspects should not be a cause for great concern, depending on the price; however, a pipe that has more than a few of these elements may be one to disregard.

  • Poorly aligned parts — Quality pipes have precisely aligned and smooth airways from the draft hole in the heel of the bowl to the lip button at the end of the mouthpiece. Any disruption in the smoke stream (such as a misaligned mortise and tenon or a smoke channel with rough internal surfaces, which can cause turbulence in the airflow and increase the smoke's production of moisture) is going to cause problems. Some pipes are purposely designed with some type of "moisture trap" that does work well for many, but it's something to get accustomed to. Misalignment of the smoke hole can also cause a whistling sound as air travels through it, and no one wants a whistling pipe.
  • Pipe Cleaner test — This is an exercise that is not essential in all pipes but is useful for identifying airflow interruptions. Simply run a pipe cleaner from the lip button down into the heel of the bowl. You'll want to be able to perform this task during a smoke to wick moisture from the airway and sometimes to clear the heel of tobacco that has lodged against the smoke hole and is interrupting airflow. However, if System pipes or filters are attractive to you, be aware that they will impede the pipe cleaner. It is not a design flaw; in these cases, it's a design attribute, with the pipe deliberately designed this way as a measure to reduce moisture and irritating potential gurgle. Some fully bent pipes are likewise unable to accept a pipe cleaner all the way into the bowl because of the acute angle of the shank/stem and the bowl. One of the considerations for pipe purchases is how important it is to your own smoking process to run pipe cleaners through the pipe while they are fully assembled.
  • Overly sharp edges — Check the mouthpiece carefully. If the lip button has sharp edges that have not been rounded off, there's potential for discomfort. Excessive sharpness is an indication of accelerated production and possibly lower quality overall.

Being aware of negative aspects is imperative, but it's also necessary to recognize the factors that contribute to high performance:

  • Grain — The more uniform the grain, and the tighter the grain, the higher the price of the pipe, but overall, this has little to no effect on the smoking quality. Excellent grain is rare, and pipes that display uniformity in this characteristic are often more expensive.
  • Weight — Generally, the lighter a pipe is, if it's made of briar, the better it will smoke. It's almost impossible to determine before you've handled a lot of pipes and know what to expect in terms of weight, but by comparing two pipes of the same shape and size, it's easy to determine which is lighter. The weight of small objects like pipes may seem an insignificant element, but it's an indicator of curing and smoking potential. Each block of briar has saps and resins that increase the density of the wood. Sawmills where the briar is prepared boil the wood to remove impurities and saps, but factories and artisans also add air-curing time to additionally remove these compounds. Not only is a lighter pipe more comfortable to hold and clench, but it is likely to smoke cooler because of the reduced density and heat conductivity.
  • Sandpits — Sandpits happen, and there really isn't anything wrong with them, but the fewer of them in a pipe, the more attractive it may be. Sandblasted and rusticated pipes are not troubled by these natural defects in the wood because their texture and color hides them. A pipe without sand pits will not smoke better, but again, it's an indicator of the rarity of that piece of wood and comes with a premium price. Briar blocks are like diamonds. The more flawless and consistent it is, the rarer it is, and people will pay premium prices for flawlessness.
  • Fit and finish — The pipe should look as if it was made with care. There should not be any obvious sandpaper or file marks, which are most often found around the juncture of the shank and the bowl but may be anywhere depending on the complexity of the shape. Additionally, you may wish to avoid pipes whose tobacco chambers are color stained. It's something that happens with dip-staining, in which color is applied by dipping the entire stummel into stain (a stummel is the entire pipe except for the mouthpiece and any attached accents like bands at the end of the shank). It makes construction and finishing faster in the workshop, but the flavor takes some time to burn through and can be unpleasant. You'll be wanting to appreciate the flavor of tobacco, not stain.
  • Draft hole — This should be as close as possible to the center of the bowl, and should align perfectly with the airhole in the stem. It should also terminate at the bottom of the bowl, not part way up the side. A misaligned draft hole can cause problems with efficient combustion, can promote moisture, and is generally to be avoided.

The good news is that here at Smokingpipes, we inspect every individual pipe for all of these potential issues and are available on the phone or via email to answer questions and confirm the characteristics of any pipe. So another consideration when buying a pipe is to do so through a reputable shop where bad pipes are not tolerated.

Financial Considerations:

Buy the best tobacco pipe that you can justify

Buy the best that you can justify. This is the basic financial rule of pipe purchasing, and of almost any other purchase. Pipes are available in a vast range of prices, from under $20.00 to well into the $1,000s, with plenty of well-made pipes in each price category. You should strive for the greatest value/price ratio. The reason this is the final consideration is that pipes are not cheap or expensive; they are either good smokers, or bad smokers, and without careful consideration of the aesthetics and mechanics, a cheap pipe and an expensive pipe are equally likely to be a good smoking instrument or a deficient one.

It isn't entirely dependent on great construction; the briar itself has a large impact on how well a pipe will smoke, and two pipes made from the same block of wood can have very different smoking characteristics. A well-made, well-engineered, carefully finished pipe has a higher likelihood of smoking well because every element has been completed to maximize the potential of that pipe. But even cheaply made pipes can be great smokers if the briar is right.

That's why many smokers have favorite pipe makers: They know that, for example, with a particular brand they have a 90 percent chance of a great pipe whereas another brand that is cheaply made may provide only a 40 percent chance. And much of that is dependent on the individual, the way they load a bowl, their preferred moisture level for their tobacco, the tobacco cut, and the pressure employed in tamping the tobacco. There are many confounding factors, but it will all become second nature quite quickly.

The Metaphysical:

Tobacco Pipe Smoking

The non-material aspects of pipe smoking may be the most important to consider. It sounds strange to claim that a pipe can be a friend and companion, but as years pass and hundreds of bowls have been smoked under every conceivable circumstance, a pipe becomes part of the landscape of one's life. Through tough times and great times, a pipe accompanies us.

A pipe brings with it stress relief and the time to think. Enveloped in wreathes of pipe smoke, one almost feels as though the rest of the world is walled off. A pipe brings with it a protective insulation from the high and sharp points of daily living. It offers comfort when most needed, and enhances those times that are celebratory. A pipe can become an extension of ourselves.

That's why it's important to choose carefully when purchasing a pipe. Insignificant flaws are easily overlooked in a friend who has been there through it all, but, as with people, major flaws indicate a pipe that may never become a friend.

Pipes can offer a contentment that is rare in this modern world. Just as you choose your friends with care, choose your pipes knowing that you're building a relationship. Some will fail you and you'll let them go, but we all want that greatest of friends, and each pipe we consider has the potential to be that lifelong confidant.

If you've been in a pipe shop while someone is purchasing a new pipe and wondered why it may be taking such a long time, perhaps it's more clear now. Pipe smokers have a number of factors to consider in a new purchase aside from the beauty of a pipe. Now, when it's your turn, you'll have a better idea of what to look for, what to avoid, and how to maximize the potential and value of every pipe you consider in the future.

Category:   Pipe Line
Tagged in:   Pipe Culture


    • Joseph Kirkland on June 5, 2022
    • Kudos. Chuck, another wonderful article. I wish I had had this essay in 1959 when I started. I have a couple of new friends who have asked me about pipe smoking. I share your articles because they are so significant and will help anyone interested in pipes. Thank you one more time.

    • SO on June 5, 2022
    • Thank you for another very informative great article.

    • PK Forehand on June 5, 2022
    • I always look forward to your articles and expanding my knowledge. I’ve been smoking about 50 years now and I feel like I’m just now learning about this wonderful world of pipes. Still smoke my first Stanwell from 1972, it’s a close friend.

    • North of Bangor on June 5, 2022
    • Thankfully I had the superb staff of Grant’s Tobaccos in San Francisco, CA (since closed) to guide my entry into pipe smoking. I was not afraid to ask questions nor take advice. Bought my first pipes there; two Grant’s house pipes and later a Peterson System. That was 1979 and I still smoke all three. 40 years later I am a happy, one or two bowl a day, contemplative pipeman.

    • Michael Cherry on June 5, 2022
    • Another gem! If you had been around when I first started to try pipe smoking, you would be in your 130's. I hope you live that long and continue to inspire, entertain and inform many more generations.As always your obedient servant.

    • Bob on June 5, 2022
    • What a well thought out, nicely written article. North of Bangor, in their comment, brings up an excellent point. Start with a reputable tobacconist, and the staff is usually (in my experience) happy to provide expert guidance, especially to someone just starting out. The bottom line is, however, the final choice is up to you.

    • Pipes & Whiskey on June 5, 2022
    • What a great article. Some of what is here, my dad and grandfather told me. While they are gone now, it is nice to see such a fine article and good advise.

    • Mike on June 21, 2022
    • Great article, as always.

    • Wayne Connors on November 3, 2022
    • Ahh, the aroma!

    • Jerry B on April 25, 2023
    • As I set here smoking a bowl I stumbled upon your article. I found it interesting and informitive. I've been smoking a pipe for many years. I walked into a Tinderbox in a mall I was shopping in. I think as I recal I wanted a break from the croud and the Pipe store had this wonderful smell coming from it. I love the smell of Pipe tobacco and that drew me into the shop. I looked at all the many pipes in the store and asked the clerk (when he was finished with a customer) what the cost of a certain pipe was. During our brief conversation he directed me to a pipe group I could afford. I remember purchesing one but don't rember the brand. I also bought some tobacco but don't remember that brand either. I was a cigarette smoker and none of this information was given to me by that store clerk. I wish he would have as that would have helped a lot. He was busy smoking a pipe and I suspect he wanted to get back to that. Needless to say I didn't continue to smoke that pipe or enjoy the tobacco I bought. It was several years later when I tried again. I went to the same store and this time the clerk was much more heplful. He suggested a book written by Carl Webber and I still have that book. It explained a lot about what your article explained. Once I finished reading that book I was very prepared to start over. That was somewhere in the late 1960's. I have been an avid pipe smoker ever sinse. I'm 75 years old and still enjoy a good pipe at least once a day. Thank you so much for your wonderful article. It brought back many plesent memories as well as a few not so plesant ones. I wish I would have had someone who would have directed me to my first pipe like the person I later found at that store. By the way the store nolonger allowed their clerks to smoke while working. I suspect it was because I was not the only person who was put off from pipe smoking because a clerk was to busy smoking to take the time to properly direct a customer in what they were purchasing.

Join the conversation:

This will not be shared with anyone

challenge image
Enter the circled word below: