Mystery Review: May 2026
Produced by Chris Herath and Nicole Weed | Edited by Ardit Hushi
Welcome to another episode of Mystery Review, our monthly series in which our panel of experts attempts to identify a mystery tobacco. For May's edition, we are joined by guest panelist Kevin Reed, Assistant Manager at Low Country Pipe and Cigar. Our guest Inquisitor is Jay Furman, long-time member of the pipe community and co-host of "P&T 3.0" podcast. Will his mysterious submission leave us bewildered, or will we correctly guess the tobacco he's presented to us? Join us as we discuss what we think this mystery smoke is and make our best guesses. Watch to the end to discover whether we succeed in the identification or crumble under the pressure.
What is The Mystery Review?
For those unfamiliar with our little game, each month, one member of our team — or sometimes an honored guest Inquisitor — selects a tobacco for us to review in a blind taste test. Then we gather around the camera, scratch our heads, and smoke, all while attempting to guess the mysterious submission, its manufacturer, and, if we're lucky, its name.
Comments
YouCan't you even push E-house and German for me?
As a female pipe smoker, I thoroughly enjoyed the guys round table mystery review.