Mystery Tobacco Review: August 2023

Welcome to another riveting installment of the Mystery Tobacco Review, a monthly series in which our panel of experts tries to identify a tobacco submitted to outwit and surprise them. This month sees the return of our own Steve Mawby as Inquisitor. Steve is our Customer Service Manager and possesses the deep tobacco knowledge necessary for helping customers who are looking for tobaccos to fit their own unique taste preferences. He is expert at identifying tobaccos even when the name is not known and only a few of the ingredients can be listed, and he has leveraged that vast knowledge in the pursuit of challenging Truett, Andy, Alan and me. Will his choice this month be beyond our abilities, or will we uncover the mystery and triumphantly prevail? The conclusion reveals all, so watch to the end!

What is The Mystery Tobacco Review?

For those unfamiliar with this little game, each month one member of our team — or sometimes an honored guest Inquisitor — selects a tobacco for us to review in a blind taste-test. Then we gather around the camera, scratch our heads, and smoke, all while attempting to guess the mysterious mixture's components, origins, and, when we're lucky, its name. There's only one rule: There are no rules.

Category:   Tobacco Talk
Tagged in:   Mystery Tobacco Reviews


    • Ben H. on August 17, 2023
    • I love watching both the mystery review videos! I was wondering what happened to Andrew. What a reentry that was! These are some of the best review videos on the internet on computers. Thanks for the entertainment and the education. I think I have a tin this in my cellar. Keep up the great work!

    • James on August 18, 2023
    • Andy is an absolute legend! MTR GOAT!

    • Bill on August 20, 2023
    • Great episode and really great to see Andy back!

    • David on August 20, 2023
    • Great video! And bravo Andy! Great to see you back. One of the many things that makes these reviews so much fun to watch is your camaraderie. It's a pleasure to see you enjoying each other and playing off each other's observations. I find myself smiling and laughing along with you.

    • Dave Chandler on August 20, 2023
    • Great episode! Quite the triumphant return for Andy!! Hearth & Home's 'Viprati' blend has long been my go-to for an uncomplicated all-day VaPer; I'd highly recommend giving that one another spin. Thanks so much for the excellent & entertaining content, fellas!

    • Matt_M on August 25, 2023
    • Andy!!! Welcome back!I am certain that you have been busy, but I am also confident in saying that you have been missed.(N.B. That is not a slap at Truett, Alan, or Shane: Andy, you just bring a laconic twist and a deep knowledge that I enjoy hearing.)This was a great episode. Nice job fighting for the “biggest miss” award. That was fun to watch. Bravo! (*Golf clap* Well played, sirs; well played.)

    • Gautam khanna on August 26, 2023
    • Great to see Andy back and what an impressive return! Keep up the great work guys. These are fun to watch

    • Papamique on September 2, 2023
    • Hey! Andy is back! Great vibes! Great Video! Loved it!

    • Lukas S on September 25, 2023
    • I haven't watched mystery tobacco in a long time, and just went back on YouTube to check it out, and I got so freaked that you stopped doing them! So glad I found it all here on your website!Please never stop making these, these are awesome :)

Join the conversation:

This will not be shared with anyone

challenge image
Enter the circled word below: