The Four Stages of P.A.D.

When I got serious about smoking premium tobaccos four or five years ago, I had a pretty small collection of pipes. There were three briars on my shelf: my first pipe, a simple Bent Brandy from a lesser-known factory, a full Bent Billiard from a marque that I'd never heard of before and haven't heard of since, and a fairly capacious Dublin that was simply stamped "Italy."

These three pipes served me fairly well. I was only smoking a few bowls of tobacco per week, and exclusively aromatic tobaccos at that. But that small rotation didn't equip me very well for my venture into tinned tobaccos. These pipes were ghosted with vanilla, chocolate, and Lord knows what other flavors, which didn't exactly bring out the best in the English and Balkan mixtures that I increasingly favored.

And these new blends were leading me to smoke much more frequently than a few times per week. I needed more pipes, so I went to work building a collection of reliable smokers — primarily English estates — and the occasional high grade. Over the past year, my tastes in tobacco have changed once again. While I still enjoy a good English or Balkan, more and more I find myself turning to Virginia and Burley blends. Again I've found myself needing to add a few more pieces to the collection. This effort has led me to reflect a bit on what we in the hobby knowingly refer to as P.A.D. — Pipe Acquisition Disorder for the un- or newly-initiated. I believe that I have now struggled with this affliction long enough to diagnose some definite stages in its progression.

1. Generalized Longing

For me, PAD usually begins with a vague desire to buy a new pipe. The object of desire is as yet unformed. I have no specific piece in mind — simply a feeling that I might like a new pipe. During this phase, I find that I spend an inordinate amount of time perusing, even for someone who happens to work here. (One benefit to working here is that we can spend as much time on the website as we like and no one minds.)

2. Choosing a Specimen

In stage two, the longing moves from the general to the particular. In the early phases of stage 2, there may be several specimens that I like, but I usually narrow it down to a single piece pretty quickly. Again, I look at the pipe's image on the website, considering its aesthetic appeal, weight, and measurements. As stage 2 progresses, I go to the Pipe Library here in the office, write the SKU number on the sign out sheet, and bring it back to my office where it sits on my desk for several hours. I continue to work, occasionally pausing to glance at the pipe, wondering how it might smoke.

3. Rationalization

Assuming that the pipe is satisfactory, I move slowly into stage 3, Rationalization. It is during this stage that my desire to take this piece home must do battle with my left brain by answering such questions as "Do you really need this pipe?", "Didn't you just buy one last month?", "How will we convince the lovely and gracious Allie that this pipe is a better investment than, say, a new range hood for the kitchen?" More often than not, my pipe-loving id pulls a Perry Mason on my reason and convinces it that this pipe is really a valuable addition to my collection. After all, in the humid South Carolina spring, pipes need to rest longer. If I trade in a few estates that I don't smoke any more, we can still buy that range hood. And compared to other hobbies, pipe smoking really isn't that expensive.

4. Consummation

Having concluded that nothing could be more reasonable than adding another pipe to the collection, I purchase the piece. I take it out of the box and handle it lovingly. But I don't smoke it. No, a new pipe must take its maiden voyage at home, where proper thought can be given to choosing the inaugural tobacco and accompanying beverage. After that first bowl, I take a great deal of pleasure in knowing that this pipe is finally mine — part of my collection, part of my rotation, an object of desire now well on its way to becoming a faithful companion.

Category:   Pipe Line
Tagged in:   Humor Newsletter Pipe Culture


    • John on April 21, 2015
    • Great Post!

    • Chip Kushner on April 21, 2015
    • I would agree with just about everything except that you have far more willpower than I. When I acquire a new pipe it seldom goes more then 5 minutes before I light it up, much less getting all the way home.

    • R. Compton on May 1, 2015
    • I relate to your plight. truly I do. I have been aflicked with P.A.D since the 70's. there is hope! I remember being so alone in my pursuit's, I only felt normal in Pipe Shop's where there were other's like me. you are not alone! with the help of a Pipe club and copious amount's of Latakia it O.K God bless you for bringing this subject to light. R.Compton

    • Greg on May 4, 2015
    • Great Post!

    • Matthew M on May 12, 2015
    • The people who say that you can't buy new friends surely haven't visited the best friend of all: SmokingPipes. Thank you all!

    • Bruce P on October 2, 2015
    • Interesting! My wife gets frustrated when I send her my "wish list" for my birthday and all that is on it are pipes and tobacco. "You don't need another pipe" has been flung at me in a vain attempt to ask for something else. The fact however remains that I DO need another pipe so the list goes unchanged.

    • Flatticus on February 10, 2016
    • I think you forgot the fifth stage. Repetition. Excellent post.

    • Howard Parsons on February 10, 2016
    • He who dies with the most pipes, wins.

    • David S. on February 10, 2016
    • Love these posts! Keep up the good work.

    • TonyR on February 10, 2016
    • I suffer from PAD real bad. Is there a cure?

    • Adam O'Neill on February 11, 2016
    • @Flatticus But does anyone REALLY forget the fifth step ;)

    • Adam O'Neill on February 11, 2016
    • @Howard Parsons Now that's a race I can get behind.

    • Adam O'Neill on February 11, 2016
    • @David S Thanks David, we will!

    • Adam O'Neill on February 11, 2016
    • @TonyR Immersion therapy? ;)

    • Horand on June 14, 2016
    • May I ask what that pipe is in the final pic?

    • Joshua Burgess on June 15, 2016
    • Horand: That was an Abe Herbaugh Smooth Bent Egg. That particular pipe didn't, in the end, become a part of my collection. But I added a different pipe from Abe not too long after. He's doing excellent work.

    • peter howard on April 6, 2018
    • The only kown therapy at this time is to buy another pipe!

    • Adam O'Neill on April 9, 2018
    • @Peter Howard Haha, indeed.

Join the conversation:

This will not be shared with anyone

challenge image
Enter the circled word below: