Cigars / Lost & Found / Paradise Lost Toro
Last Call!

Paradise Lost Toro Cigar (6 x 54)

Product Number: 007-864-0106

Your Price
$12.75 MSRP: $15.00 per Stick
Not so fast! In the "Choose one" section below, Pick an options before adding to your cart.
Sticks
Box Count: 10 Cigars
Buy A 5-Pack
Buy A Box Of 10
Sign in to add this product to your Wishlist or Favorites.

Ask a question about this product.

Details

Strength:
3/5
  • Length: 6.00 in./152.40 mm.
  • Ring Gauge: 54
  • Country: Dominican Republic
  • Wrapper Type: Maduro, San Andres
  • Wrapper Country: Mexico
  • Filler Country: Dominican Republic, Nicaragua
  • Binder Country: Dominican Republic
  • Package Type: Stick
  • Make: Handmade
  • Box Pressed: Not Box Pressed
  • Flavored: Not Flavored

About This Cigar

To say that Lost & Found is a special project is to put it somewhat mildly. Lost & Found is a clandestine endeavor created by Robert Caldwell of Caldwell Cigar Company and Tony Bellatto of La Barba Cigars. The brand itself doesn't fashion or create any of their own cigars, per se. Instead, Caldwell has utilized the potential of "lost" cigars forgotten in the vast warehouses of other manufacturers. It goes something like this: Whenever a cigar brand rolls and boxes cigars for a particular line or release, they're inevitably left with, well, leftovers — either only so many boxes were made or the series was capped at a certain number, the surplus left on the factories' shelves. Caldwell, then, "finds" these "lost" cigars, rebrands them, and offers them to consumers. While the blends' original components and company of manufacture remain anonymous, connoisseurs can count on them being from some of the most reputable names in the industry and having several years worth of age to them. Lost & Found offers some of the best kept secrets in the cigar industry and has developed a loyal following.

A collaboration between Robert Caldwell and Room101 founder Matt Booth, Paradise Lost is an aged blend that comprises a San Andres Maduro wrapper, a Dominican binder, and filler tobaccos from the Dominican Republic and Nicaragua. A delightfully balanced blend, this cigar is a medium-bodied smoke that offers tasting notes of milk, oak, pepper, and oats.

Customer Reviews

Overall Rating:
5.0
1 reviews
Something unique
December 20, 2025
Product: Lost & Found Paradise Lost Toro
I’d put this more at a 4/5 than a 3 in terms of strength. The flavor is unmistakable yet impossible to pin down completely. Definitely oats, and flavors of wood. The description they gave of milk, oak, pepper, and oats is as good a description I could come up with. There’s something about its rich dark flavor that is balanced by a refreshingly creamy lightness. This is one of those cigars that you don’t forget the flavor of, that you can summon to mind and say “yes that’s what I want”. All that and it has that first-light full-flavor construction I love. Perfect draw. Flawless burn....Read More

Customers Who Smoked Paradise Lost Toro Also Smoked: