Sutliff: D64 Queen Anne's Revenge Pipe Tobacco

The flavor text of this tobacco drew me in. Hook, line and sinker. It's alright, being in North Carolina I had to give ol' Black Beard's flagship a try. Not bad, still going to reach for buttered rum or captain black 90 percent of the time. She ain't bad though.

The taste, the room note and the smoke are fantastic. This is hands down my favorite aromatic so far. It's a pinch damp so let it dry out a while. I usually give it an hour or 2. Again, I'm new to the scene here but concerning a bulk blend, this is great. I have no idea what I'll replace this with when Sutliff is gone....Read More

I really enjoy this tobacco. It has a lot of flavor but is still a mild smoke. I keep this one around all the time.

Years ago, before the advent of the internet and Smoking Pipes . COM, the choices for tobacco was often limited to the codger blends found in drug stores with a few other blends unless you were lucky enough to be in the vicinity of a real tobacco store. I started smoking a pipe while in the Army, sometimes in places where nothing was available...in Viet Nam the only blend we could get was that stuff that came in the pale yellow pouch...far from my favorite to say the least. Later I was lucky enough to be stationed near a Tinder Box and fell for the Rum Runner blend which was my all day blend for several years. Though I moved on, I still remember the taste of it and decided to try this as rum and tobacco go well together and I was curious what vanilla would add to the blend. The sweetness is there, the vanilla is much stronger than the rum and it works. This is going in my regular rotation as I'm quite fond of vanilla aromatics and the rum is a plus....Read More

Boy I didn't like this. I couldn't taste the natural tobacco components as it was covered up by a strong artificial flavor, tasted like plastic to me. The rum flavor is nice, but it's all it has.

This has to be the best aromatic that I have had

This is my absolute favorite aromatic.

It honestly pains me to rate Queen Anne's Revenge one star. I want to love this stuff but can't, for reasons I'll detail in a moment. First, the positives. Its pouch note smells so good you want to eat it. The room note is heavenly. The taste--when I can actually get the tobacco lit--is wonderful. Rum, vanilla and all sorts of tropical island goodness. This could easily be my favorite aromatic and rate 4-5 stars. It gets a single star because the 4 oz. I received is a dark, wet, sticky, goopy mess that is extremely difficult to light and nearly impossible to keep lit. I let some sit out and tried it after an hour or two. Didn't help. 24 hours? Nope, still soggy and barely burned. Same after 48 hours. Here we are 6 days later and it still won't burn. When I placed my order the product page said they only had 8 or 9 oz. left, so maybe I got Queen Anne's sloppy seconds that settled at the bottom of her bilge, I mean bin. I'm going to leave the bag open and see if it ever dries out. If not, I'll jar it up or mix it with something drier and hope for the best....Read More

A terrific aromatic, very heavy in the rum department. If you like a rum cavendish, this is for you!

I’da cut Teach’s head off meeself just fer a bowl full o this fyne tobaccy!! Hahaaaaarrrr!! Tis truly one of thee fynest rum soaked aromatics in the seven seas! Smooth, cool, delicious, and intoxicating! Just likes mee rum! You bilge suckin sea ratts ain't worthy of this!!